Fracture Treatment Design


Description

What fracture does this proppant mass buy, how do you pump it, and how much does it raise the well's productivity? You enter the reservoir and drainage area, the proppant, the rock, the fluid and leakoff, and the minifrac's closure and ISIP. You read off the optimum half-length and dimensionless conductivity, the geometry model the barriers allow, an eight-stage pump schedule, whether the proppant is carried and what conductivity survives closure, and the folds of increase. Field units; the PO add-in is needed.

How to use it: The job is made up. On the Screening sheet, take k and h from a well test, the drainage area from the spacing, the proppant's density, pack porosity and conductivity at closure from the vendor's data, E and nu from the logs, and the leakoff coefficient and the closure from a minifrac (the DFIT workbook). Check on the Geometry sheet which model the height containment picks, then set the blender's limit from the crew on the Pump Schedule sheet and the proppant tests on the Proppant sheet. The Summary holds every headline number and the checks under one verdict.

Method: The proppant number is 2 kf Vprop/(k Vres); the optimum dimensionless conductivity and half-length follow from it. The propped conductivity is kf wp, wp from the proppant mass over the propped volume, and the skin follows from wp. The folds of increase at the design half-length are (ln(xe/sqrt(pi)/rw) - 0.75) over that plus the skin. The geometry models are Nolte's material balance per wing, q t = A (w + 2 KL CL sqrt(t)), with A = hf L for PKN and KGD and pi R^2/2 for the radial fracture; each pass moves ln L by ln(te/t) over d ln t/d ln L and the balance closes in five Newton passes. The height the PKN net pressure opens between symmetric barriers (Simonson) picks the model: PKN when L/hf is at least 1, KGD when it is shorter, radial when the barriers do not hold the height. The pad fraction is (1 - eta)/(1 + eta). The proppant ramp c(x) = ce x^e gives each of the eight equal-slurry stages its share, so the stages place the designed mass exactly, and the flush follows. Settling is Stokes' in a Newtonian or a power-law fluid, replaced by the intermediate (Allen) law above the Stokes limit; the transport ratio is the slurry velocity over the settling velocity. The conductivity kept in the well at closure and the fines follow from the lab conductivity and crush tests.

Example: The frac family's reference job, made up: 100,000 lbm of 20/40 sand at 165 lb/ft3 into a 100 ft high fracture in rock with E = 4e6 psi, pumped at 15 bbl/min a wing in 200 cp gel, with a Carter leakoff coefficient of 0.0015 ft/sqrt(min), at 8,000 ft TVD, shut in at 2,650 psi at surface with 8.5 ppg in the hole. The worked example on the Test Cases sheet checks every headline number it reaches.

Validity

The design is a screening: the proppant mass, the pad and the fluid are given, not chosen. The geometry models are steady state: the fracture does not screen out, the fluid is incompressible and non-tempered, and the leakoff is Carter's coefficient with an opening-time distribution factor. The add-in has no functions for a pseudo-3D geometry or for matching the measured net pressure against the model. The uplift is the folds of increase at the design half-length against an unstimulated well in the same area, not an economic result: there is no cost, no NPV and no risk model here. The settling assumes a rigid spherical particle. Vertical well, field units.

References

  • Economides, M.J., Oligney, T.E. and Valko, P. (2002). Modern Fracture Design: Theory, Methodology, and Applications. Wiley (unified fracture design, proppant number, dimensionless conductivity).
  • Economides, M.J., Watters, T.R. and Vinkelnburg, R.W. (1993). Theory of Fracture Design. Schlumberger (PKN, KGD and radial geometry).
  • Nolte, R.G. and Economides, M.J. (1991). Fracturing Systems. In Reservoir Stimulation (ed. Economides and Martin), ch. 8 and 9 (material balance, proppant ramp).
  • Economides, M.J. and Martin, G.P. (2007). Fracture Design and Analysis. In Reservoir Stimulation, 3rd ed. (Simonson containment).

Inputs

Input Unit Default Name
Formation permeability, k mD 0.5 FTS_K
Net pay thickness, h ft 50 FTS_H
Side of the square drainage area, xe ft 2640 FTS_Xe
Wellbore radius, rw ft 0.354 FTS_Rw
Proppant mass placed, both wings lbm 100000 FTS_Mass
Proppant grain density, rp lb/ft3 165 FTS_RhoP
Porosity of the proppant pack, phip — 0.38 FTS_PhiP
Pack permeability at closure, damage included, kf mD 60000 FTS_Kf
Design half-length, xf ft 600 FTS_Xf
Fracture height, hf ft 100 FTS_Hf
Injection rate per wing, qi bbl/min 15 FTS_Q
Fracturing fluid viscosity cP 200 FTS_Mu
Young's modulus, E psi 4000000 FTS_E
Poisson's ratio, nu — 0.25 FTS_Nu
Carter leakoff coefficient, CL ft/√min 0.0015 FTS_CL
Opening-time distribution factor, KL — 1.5 FTS_KL
ISIP read at surface psi 2650 FTS_IsipSurf
Fluid density in the wellbore at shut-in ppg 8.5 FTS_RhoFluid
True vertical depth of the perforations ft 8000 FTS_Tvd
Closure stress (from the minifrac) psi 5600 FTS_Closure
Design CfD allowed within this factor of the optimum — 2 FTS_Band
Net pressure allowed within this factor of PKN's — 1.5 FTS_PnetBand
Highest proppant concentration the blender adds ppga 12 FTS_MaxConc
Injection rate per wing, qi (Geometry) bbl/min 15 FTM_Q
Fracturing fluid viscosity (Geometry) cP 200 FTM_Mu
Pumping time, te min 27.78 FTM_Te
Fracture height between the barriers, hf ft 100 FTM_Hf
Young's modulus, E (Geometry) psi 4000000 FTM_E
Poisson's ratio, nu (Geometry) — 0.25 FTM_Nu
Carter leakoff coefficient, CL (Geometry) ft/√min 0.0015 FTM_CL
Opening-time distribution factor, KL (Geometry) — 1.5 FTM_KL
Stress contrast to the barriers above and below psi 1500 FTM_Dsig
Height growth allowed, opened height over hf — 1.25 FTM_HMax
Injection rate, both wings bbl/min 30 FTP_Q
Pumping time to the end of the proppant, te min 27.78 FTP_Te
Fluid efficiency at the end of pumping, eta % 0.3918 FTP_Eta
Proppant mass to place, both wings lbm 100000 FTP_Mass
Proppant grain density, rp (Pump Schedule) lb/ft3 165 FTP_RhoP
Casing capacity to the perforations (5.5 in, 17 lb/ft) bbl/ft 0.0232 FTP_Cap
Measured depth to the top perforation ft 8000 FTP_Md
Highest proppant concentration the blender adds (Pump Schedule) ppga 12 FTP_MaxConc
Particle diameter, dp (20/40 mesh) in 0.025 FTR_Dp
Proppant grain density, rp (Proppant) lbm/gal 22.07 FTR_RhoP
Proppant added to clean fluid ppga 6 FTR_Ca
Fluid density, rf ppg 8.5 FTR_RhoF
Rheology (1 Newtonian, 2 power law) — 2 FTR_Fluid
Newtonian viscosity cP 100 FTR_Mu
Power-law flow behaviour index, n — 0.45 FTR_N
Power-law consistency index, K lbf.s/ft2 0.025 FTR_Kp
Average fracture width while pumping in 0.2 FTR_W
Fracture height, hf (Proppant) ft 100 FTR_Hf
Injection rate per wing (Proppant) bbl/min 15 FTR_Q
Distance to carry the proppant (half-length) ft 600 FTR_L
Closure stress psi 5600 FTR_Closure
Flowing bottomhole pressure psi 2000 FTR_Pwf
Lab conductivity at the lower test stress mD-ft 4000 FTR_KfwLo
Lower conductivity test stress psi 2000 FTR_SigLo
Lab conductivity at the higher test stress mD-ft 2000 FTR_KfwHi
Higher conductivity test stress psi 6000 FTR_SigHi
Share of the lab conductivity kept in the well % 0.5 FTR_Retained
Lower crush-test stress psi 4000 FTR_CrushLo
Fines at the lower crush-test stress % 0.06 FTR_FinesLo
Higher crush-test stress psi 6000 FTR_CrushHi
Fines at the higher crush-test stress % 0.14 FTR_FinesHi
Stokes drag constant, Cd = 24/Re — 24 FTR_CdStokes
Intermediate-law coefficient, Cd = a/Re^b — 18.5 FTR_CdA
Intermediate-law exponent, b — 0.6 FTR_CdB
Particle Reynolds number where Stokes ends — 2 FTR_ReStokes
Reynolds number where the intermediate law ends — 500 FTR_ReMax
Settling allowed before the tip, share of height % 0.5 FTR_SettleMax
Crushed fines allowed (the K-value's 10 per cent) % 0.1 FTR_FinesMax

Sheets

  • Guide — what the workbook answers, the example treatment, what it leaves out and the order to work through its sheets.
  • Screening — unified fracture design: the proppant mass fixes the proppant number, and the optimum dimensionless conductivity and half-length follow; the design's propped width, conductivity, skin and folds of increase; the geometry while pumping, Nolte's pumping time, fluid efficiency and pad; the ISIP and net pressure at shut-in; and the folds of increase against half-length for the same proppant mass.
  • Geometry — PKN, KGD and radial solved side by side on Nolte's material balance by Newton passes, and the Simonson height containment that picks the model.
  • Pump Schedule — Nolte's pad and proppant ramp cut into eight equal slurry stages plus the flush, the job totals, the proppant balance and the blender limit, with the staged concentration charted against the ramp.
  • Proppant — the proppant's settling velocity, its transport along the fracture, the conductivity kept in the well at closure and the fines the crush test gives.
  • Summary — every headline number and the checks under one verdict.
  • Test Cases — the worked example and other cases, with expected and computed results.

Two charts: the folds of increase on Screening, the staged concentration on Pump Schedule.

Functions used

PO.FRAC.Design.UFDPO.FRAC.Design.ConductivityPO.FRAC.Design.PadFractionPO.FRAC.Eval.ISIPPO.FRAC.PKNPO.FRAC.KGDPO.FRAC.RadialPO.FRAC.Leakoff.EffPO.FRAC.WellPO.FRAC.Proppant

Names (157)

NameRefers toComment
PO.FRAC.Design.ConductivityLAMBDA =LAMBDA(mass, rho_p, phi_p, xf, hf, kf, IF(OR(mass<0, rho_p<=0, phi_p<0, phi_p>=1, xf<=0, hf<=0, kf<0), NA(), kf*mass/((1-phi_p)*rho_p)/(2*xf*hf))) Propped fracture conductivity kf·wp [md·ft] from the proppant mass: wp = mass/((1 − φp)·ρp)/(2·xf·hf), the pack spread over both wings after closure.
PO.FRAC.Design.PadFractionLAMBDA =LAMBDA(eta, IF(OR(eta<=0, eta>1), NA(), (1-eta)/(1+eta))) Nolte's pad fraction of the slurry volume, ε = (1 − η)/(1 + η), from the fluid efficiency η; also the exponent of the proppant ramp. #N/A outside 0 < η ≤ 1.
PO.FRAC.Design.UFDLAMBDA =LAMBDA(mass, rho_p, phi_p, kf, k, h, hf, xe, output, IF(OR(mass<=0, rho_p<=0, phi_p<0, phi_p>=1, kf<=0, k<=0, h<=0, hf<=0, xe<=0), NA(), LET(vbulk, mass/((1-phi_p)*rho_p), vpay, vbulk*MIN(1, h/hf), np, 2*kf*vpay/(k*xe^2*h), lnp, LN(np), cfd, IF(np<=0.1, 1.6, IF(np<=10, 1.6+EXP((-0.583+1.48*lnp)/(1+0.142*lnp)), np)), jd, IF(np<=0.1, 1/(0.99-0.5*lnp), 6/PI()-EXP((0.423-0.311*np-0.089*np^2)/(1+0.667*np+0.015*np^2))), xf, SQRT(kf*vpay/2/(cfd*h*k)), IF(output="Np", np, IF(output="CfD", cfd, IF(output="JD", jd, IF(output="xf", xf, IF(output="w", 12*vpay/2/(xf*h), NA())))))))) Unified fracture design: from the proppant mass, output "Np" (proppant number), "CfD" (optimum conductivity), "JD" (max productivity index), "xf" (optimum half-length, ft) or "w" (propped width, in).
PO.FRAC.Eval.ISIPLAMBDA =LAMBDA(isip_surf, rho_fluid, tvd, closure, output, IF(OR(rho_fluid<0, tvd<=0), NA(), LET(isip_bh, isip_surf+0.052*rho_fluid*tvd, IF(output="ISIP", isip_bh, IF(output="Pnet", isip_bh-closure, IF(output="Gradient", isip_bh/tvd, NA())))))) Instantaneous shut-in pressure at the fracture from the surface ISIP plus the static column 0.052·ρ·TVD; output "ISIP" (psi), "Pnet" (ISIP − closure, psi) or "Gradient" (psi/ft).
PO.FRAC.Proppant.ConductivityLAMBDA =LAMBDA(kfw_lo, sigma_lo, kfw_hi, sigma_hi, sigma_eff, retained, IF(OR(kfw_lo<=0, kfw_hi<=0, sigma_hi=sigma_lo, retained<0, retained>1), NA(), retained*kfw_lo*EXP(LN(kfw_hi/kfw_lo)*(sigma_eff-sigma_lo)/(sigma_hi-sigma_lo)))) Proppant pack conductivity at an effective closure stress [md·ft]: log-linear in stress through two lab points, times the share retained after gel damage, embedment and fines.
PO.FRAC.Proppant.CrushingLAMBDA =LAMBDA(sigma_c, pwf, sigma_lo, fines_lo, sigma_hi, fines_hi, IF(OR(fines_lo<=0, fines_hi<=0, sigma_hi=sigma_lo), NA(), MIN(1, fines_lo*EXP(LN(fines_hi/fines_lo)*(MAX(0, sigma_c-pwf)-sigma_lo)/(sigma_hi-sigma_lo))))) Crushed fines (fraction) at the pack's effective stress, closure less flowing pressure: log-linear in stress through two crush-test points (ISO 13503-2), capped at 1.
FTM_CL Geometry!$B$10
FTM_Compare Geometry!$A$23:$D$26
FTM_Dsig Geometry!$B$13
FTM_E Geometry!$B$8
FTM_HMax Geometry!$B$14
FTM_Hf Geometry!$B$7
FTM_Inputs Geometry!$B$4:$B$14
FTM_KL Geometry!$B$11
FTM_KgdL Geometry!$C$23
FTM_Model Geometry!$B$51
FTM_ModelCheck Geometry!$B$55
FTM_ModelCheckNote Geometry!$C$55
FTM_Mu Geometry!$B$5
FTM_Nu Geometry!$B$9
FTM_Passes Geometry!$B$61
FTM_PickEta Geometry!$B$53
FTM_PickL Geometry!$B$52
FTM_PknL Geometry!$B$23
FTM_Q Geometry!$B$4
FTM_RadR Geometry!$D$23
FTM_Results Geometry!$B$17:$B$55
FTM_SolveCheck Geometry!$B$54
FTM_SolveCheckNote Geometry!$C$54
FTM_SolveTol Geometry!$B$60
FTM_Solver Geometry!$A$66:$M$71
FTM_Te Geometry!$B$6
FTP_BalTol 'Pump Schedule'!$B$36
FTP_BalanceCheck 'Pump Schedule'!$B$31
FTP_BalanceCheckNote 'Pump Schedule'!$C$31
FTP_BlenderCheck 'Pump Schedule'!$B$32
FTP_BlenderCheckNote 'Pump Schedule'!$C$32
FTP_CaEnd 'Pump Schedule'!$B$22
FTP_Cap 'Pump Schedule'!$B$10
FTP_Eps 'Pump Schedule'!$B$15
FTP_Eta 'Pump Schedule'!$B$6
FTP_EtaCheck 'Pump Schedule'!$B$30
FTP_EtaCheckNote 'Pump Schedule'!$C$30
FTP_Fluid 'Pump Schedule'!$B$26
FTP_Flush 'Pump Schedule'!$B$25
FTP_Inputs 'Pump Schedule'!$B$4:$B$12
FTP_Mass 'Pump Schedule'!$B$7
FTP_MaxConc 'Pump Schedule'!$B$12
FTP_MaxStage 'Pump Schedule'!$B$29
FTP_Md 'Pump Schedule'!$B$11
FTP_PadVol 'Pump Schedule'!$B$17
FTP_Placed 'Pump Schedule'!$B$24
FTP_Pumped 'Pump Schedule'!$B$27
FTP_Q 'Pump Schedule'!$B$4
FTP_Ramp 'Pump Schedule'!$A$58:$C$75
FTP_Results 'Pump Schedule'!$B$15:$B$32
FTP_RhoP 'Pump Schedule'!$B$8
FTP_Stages 'Pump Schedule'!$A$43:$I$52
FTP_Te 'Pump Schedule'!$B$5
FTP_Time 'Pump Schedule'!$B$28
FTR_Ca Proppant!$B$6
FTR_CdA Proppant!$B$32
FTR_CdB Proppant!$B$33
FTR_CdStokes Proppant!$B$31
FTR_Check Proppant!$B$63
FTR_CheckNote Proppant!$C$63
FTR_Closure Proppant!$B$19
FTR_CrushCheck Proppant!$B$65
FTR_CrushCheckNote Proppant!$C$65
FTR_CrushHi Proppant!$B$28
FTR_CrushLo Proppant!$B$26
FTR_Dp Proppant!$B$4
FTR_Ds Proppant!$B$55
FTR_Fines Proppant!$B$62
FTR_FinesHi Proppant!$B$29
FTR_FinesLo Proppant!$B$27
FTR_FinesMax Proppant!$B$37
FTR_Fluid Proppant!$B$9
FTR_Hf Proppant!$B$15
FTR_Inputs Proppant!$B$4:$B$37
FTR_Kfw Proppant!$B$60
FTR_KfwHi Proppant!$B$23
FTR_KfwLo Proppant!$B$21
FTR_Kp Proppant!$B$12
FTR_L Proppant!$B$17
FTR_Mu Proppant!$B$10
FTR_N Proppant!$B$11
FTR_Pwf Proppant!$B$20
FTR_Q Proppant!$B$16
FTR_ReMax Proppant!$B$35
FTR_ReStokes Proppant!$B$34
FTR_Results Proppant!$B$40:$B$65
FTR_Retained Proppant!$B$25
FTR_RhoF Proppant!$B$8
FTR_RhoP Proppant!$B$5
FTR_SettleMax Proppant!$B$36
FTR_SigEff Proppant!$B$58
FTR_SigHi Proppant!$B$24
FTR_SigLo Proppant!$B$22
FTR_TR Proppant!$B$53
FTR_TransportCheck Proppant!$B$64
FTR_TransportCheckNote Proppant!$C$64
FTR_Vs Proppant!$B$50
FTR_VsFree Proppant!$B$47
FTR_W Proppant!$B$14
FTS_Band Screening!$B$27
FTS_CL Screening!$B$20
FTS_CaEnd Screening!$B$59
FTS_Cfd Screening!$B$40
FTS_CfdOpt Screening!$B$33
FTS_CfdRatio Screening!$B$41
FTS_Check Screening!$B$65
FTS_CheckNote Screening!$C$65
FTS_Closure Screening!$B$26
FTS_Cond Screening!$B$38
FTS_Curve Screening!$A$73:$E$89
FTS_E Screening!$B$18
FTS_Eta Screening!$B$54
FTS_Foi Screening!$B$43
FTS_H Screening!$B$5
FTS_Hf Screening!$B$15
FTS_Inputs Screening!$B$4:$B$29
FTS_IsipBh Screening!$B$61
FTS_IsipSurf Screening!$B$23
FTS_JdMax Screening!$B$34
FTS_K Screening!$B$4
FTS_KL Screening!$B$21
FTS_Kf Screening!$B$12
FTS_Mass Screening!$B$9
FTS_MaxConc Screening!$B$29
FTS_Mu Screening!$B$17
FTS_Np Screening!$B$32
FTS_Nu Screening!$B$19
FTS_Pad Screening!$B$55
FTS_PhiP Screening!$B$11
FTS_PknPnet Screening!$B$49
FTS_PlaceCheck Screening!$B$66
FTS_PlaceCheckNote Screening!$C$66
FTS_Pnet Screening!$B$62
FTS_PnetBand Screening!$B$28
FTS_PnetCheck Screening!$B$67
FTS_PnetCheckNote Screening!$C$67
FTS_Q Screening!$B$16
FTS_Results Screening!$B$32:$B$67
FTS_RhoFluid Screening!$B$24
FTS_RhoP Screening!$B$10
FTS_Rw Screening!$B$7
FTS_Skin Screening!$B$42
FTS_Te Screening!$B$52
FTS_Tvd Screening!$B$25
FTS_Xe Screening!$B$6
FTS_Xf Screening!$B$14
FTS_XfOpt Screening!$B$35
FTU_Checks Summary!$B$28:$B$38
FTU_Overall Summary!$B$26
FTU_OverallNote Summary!$C$26
FTU_Results Summary!$B$4:$B$23

Details

Opens inNeeds the Petroleum Office add-in: its PO functions show #NAME? without it once Excel recalculates. Needs Microsoft 365 or Excel 2024: it uses functions Excel 2016 doesn't have, such as named LAMBDAs, which show #NAME? there.
FileFracTreatmentDesign.xlsx, 60 KB
CategoryDrilling
For agents and tools Descriptor (.md)
Tags:
frachydraulic-fracturefracture-geometryunified-fracture-designpump-scheduleproppantproppant-concentrationfracturing

Need a workbook we don't have? Suggest a Workbook