---
id: po.wb.al.lift-selection
title: Artificial Lift Selection
summary: "Which artificial-lift method suits a well, from a six-method screen against editable limits to first-pass ESP, gas-lift, rod-pump and plunger sizing."
category: Production
requires:
  - po-addin
  - excel-365
tags:
  - artificial-lift
  - esp
  - gas-lift
  - rod-pump
---

## Description

Which artificial-lift method fits this well, and what would the leading ones take? You enter the liquid rate, lift depth, temperature, deviation, gas-liquid ratio, sand and the power on site; the workbook scores six methods against editable typical and maximum ranges and sizes ESP, gas lift, rod pump and plunger lift to a first pass. You read off the ranked shortlist with each method's reasons, the headline sizes, and an illustrative power and cost comparison. The input values are synthetic, not equipment specifications or field measurements.

**How to use it:** Enter the well and the power available on the Screen sheet, and replace the method limits in its table with verified ranges for your equipment. On the First pass sheet, replace the example pump curve and the gas-lift, rod-pump and plunger assumptions with the well's own; the ESP's invalid-case zeros are placeholders, so resolve its checks. On the Comparison sheet, set the operating hours, period, unit cost, capital and each method's system efficiency; plunger lift needs your own efficiency. The Summary gathers the shortlist, the headline sizes, the comparison and every check.

**Method:** The screen gives each method seven scores (rate, depth, temperature, deviation, GLR, sand and power) from its typical and maximum ranges: 2 inside the typical range, 1 past it, 0 outside the maximum. A zero rules a method out. Survivors rank by total score, with efficiency as a tie-break. The first pass uses the screened well and explicit additional inputs to estimate each covered method's headline sizing values; the corresponding blueprints and detailed workbooks keep the full design workflows.

The comparison estimates theoretical mechanical input as liquid hydraulic power divided by an editable system efficiency; it is not a measurement or purchased electrical power. All four methods use the screen's target rate; ESP lifts against its target-rate TDH, the others against the assumed lift depth. Annual illustrative equivalent cost is mechanical kW times assumed annual operating hours times an illustrative unit cost; the period total adds assumed capital. Cost per barrel divides the period total by the target rate times operating days and years. No discounting, maintenance, fuel conversion or production difference is modelled. All unit and capital costs are illustrative editable assumptions, not a sourced price list. The Weatherford system-efficiency midpoints from the screening blueprint are starting assumptions, not vendor guarantees. Plunger lift has no published efficiency in that source; it shows as n/a until you supply a positive efficiency.

**Example:** At 1600 STB/d, 7500 ft TVD, 180 F and 300 scf/STB with no sand and both power sources available, ESP and gas lift score 14, followed by rod pump at 13. Jet pump also passes the screen. The synthetic first-pass sizing is not automatically a feasible selection.

## Validity

This is screening, not final equipment design. Replace well data, vendor curves and limits with verified inputs. ESP invalid-case placeholders are not valid designs; resolve its checks. Gas-lift compressor electricity cannot be inferred from liquid hydraulic power. Plunger lift uses well gas: the screening source gives no plunger efficiency, so without a positive user assumption it is marked not comparable. PCP and jet pump, when screened in, are not sized: the workbook has no first-pass sizing for them; refer to their method limits and row sources on the Screen sheet. Rod displacement is not a complete rod-string, load, gearbox or power design. The detailed designs are the ESP System Design (`po.wb.esp.design`), Continuous Gas-Lift Design (`po.wb.gl.continuous-design`) and Rod Pump System Design (`po.wb.rp.rod-pump-design`) workbooks; use the plunger-lift blueprint `po.bp.vfp.plunger.lift` for a detailed plunger case. The add-in has no function for the ESP optimum frequency or for the Gibbs rod-pump dynamometer card and its diagnosis. Compare with measurements and vendor analyses.

## References

- `po.bp.well-perf.lift.selection`, `po.bp.esp.operating.point`, `po.bp.gl.injection.pressure`, `po.bp.rp.pump.sizing`, `po.bp.rp.system.design`, `po.bp.vfp.plunger.lift`.
- Weatherford artificial-lift comparison as reproduced in the source blueprint's cited public slide deck; IPIECA (2023), "Artificial lift", used as a cross-check with differences attributed per row.

## Inputs

| Input | Unit | Default | Name |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liquid rate to lift | STB/d | 1600 | `LSS_Q` |
| Lift depth TVD | ft | 7500 | `LSS_D` |
| Temperature at lift depth | F | 180 | `LSS_T` |
| Deviation at lift depth | deg | 0 | `LSS_Dev` |
| Producing gas-liquid ratio | scf/STB | 300 | `LSS_GLR` |
| Sand: 0 none, 1 some, 2 severe | — | 0 | `LSS_Sand` |
| Electricity: 1 yes, 0 no | — | 1 | `LSS_Elec` |
| Gas: 1 yes, 0 no | — | 1 | `LSS_Gas` |
| Operating hours per year | hr/year | 8000 | `LSC_Hours` |
| Comparison period | years | 1 | `LSC_Years` |
| Illustrative cost per equivalent kWh | currency/kWh | 0.1 | `LSC_UnitCost` |
| Efficiency (fraction): ESP, gas lift, rod pump, plunger lift | — | 0.475, 0.2, 0.525; plunger lift unavailable unless you supply it | `LSC_Eff1` through `LSC_Eff4` |
| Given plunger diameter, not selected | in | 1.5 | `LSR_Dp` |
| Effective stroke | in | 76.1 | `LSR_Sp` |
| Pumping speed: test | spm | 8 | `LSR_N` |
| Maximum assumed speed | spm | 12 | `LSR_MaxN` |

## Sheets

- `Guide` — the workflow and the limits of a screening workbook.
- `Screen` — the well and power on site, the six methods' typical and maximum ranges with their sources, the seven scores per method, and the ranked shortlist with each method's reasons.
- `First pass` — first-pass ESP design point, continuous gas-lift injection depth, rod-pump displacement and rod system, and plunger-lift loading, feasibility and cycle, all on the screened well.
- `Comparison` — theoretical mechanical input, annual and period cost and cost per barrel for ESP, gas lift, rod pump and plunger lift on common, illustrative assumptions.
- `Summary` — the shortlist, the headline sizes, the comparison and every check under one verdict.
- `Test Cases` — the worked example and other cases, with expected and computed results.

## Functions used

`PO.ESP.Nodal.Drawdown`, `.Nodal.Psuction`, `.Nodal.Submergence`, `PO.ESP.System.Hfric`, `PO.ESP.TDH`, `PO.ESP.Curve.Head`, `.Curve.Efficiency`, `PO.ESP.Stages`, `PO.ESP.HydraulicHP`, `PO.ESP.BrakeHP`, `PO.ESP.Head.ToPressure`, `PO.GL.Inj.Qgi`, `.Inj.Eff`, `.Inj.Grad`, `.Inj.Pd`, `PO.PVT.Tpc.ByStanding`, `PO.PVT.Ppc.ByStanding`, `PO.PVT.Z.ByDAK`, `PO.VFP.HagedornBrown.Pin`, `PO.RP.Rod.Area`, `PO.RP.Rod.Wair`, `PO.RP.Pump.Displacement`, `.Pump.Disp.Eff`, `.Pump.Fillage`, `.Pump.NetLift`, `PO.RP.Load.FluidLoad`, `.Load.F1`, `.Load.PPRL.Mills`, `PO.RP.Torque.PRHP`, `PO.RP.Fluidlevel.Echo` (LAMBDA), `PO.PE.Loading.TurnerRate` (LAMBDA), `PO.PE.Plunger.Feasibility` (LAMBDA) and `PO.PE.Plunger.Cycle` (LAMBDA).
